A follow-on to I Want My Hat Back, this story is about a little fish who steals a hat from a big fish and thinks he can get away with it. He believes he’s perfectly justified in stealing the hat because he thinks it suits him better than it did the big fish. But the big fish notices the missing hat and chases after the little fish. The little fish hides and, although a crab has seen him, he trusts the crab to keep his secret safe. But will the crab stay true to his word? What will happen to the little fish?!